Tilda Swinton
Her shapeless black gown that seemed to
have lost a sleeve, along with the
minimal makeup and horrid boy-cut hair
all made Swinton look like a
transvestite that had been the victim of
a mugging.
Runner-up Diablo Cody
Trying way, way, way too
hard to show just how "different" she
is, Cody's shapeless animal print muumuu
just looked stupid and a little sad.
Best Dressed
Ruby Dee
Even though I've never seen so many red
dresses (if anyone was trying to be
different by wearing red, it sure didn't
work!), Dee pulled it off the best.
Elegant and age-appropriate, she looked
the classiest of all.
Worst Accessory
Nicole Kidman's necklace
Kidman's drippy, droopy, dangly bling
looked like a giant bottle of glitter
threw up on her.
Best Accessory
Jennifer Garner's necklace
It should've been gaudy, but Garner's
collar-like diamond choker was anything
but.
Worst Hair
John Travolta
It looked like his hair had been painted
on.
Best Hair
Marion Cotillard
Tough choice this year. With so many
elegant 'dos, Cotillard wins it with her
side-swept, soft curls.
Least Charming
George Clooney
On the red carpet, Clooney came off as
just the most arrogant - not to mention
extremely unfunny - jerk I've ever seen.
Most Charming
Miley Cyrus
Hard to believe the composed and totally
charming Cyrus is so young. Some of the
adults could learn a thing or two.
Worst Acceptance Speech
Karen Baker Landers and
Per Hallberg
(Sound Editing, The Bourne Ultimatum)
Stumbling and bumbling and blanking
completely, Landers proclaimed "we
planned [the speech]". Something no one
should ever
admit doing.
Best Acceptance Speech
Javier Bardem
(Supporting Actor, No Country for Old
Men)
Speaking lightning-fast, but losing
nothing. His speech to his mom needed no
translation. It was very sweet.
Worst Song Presentation
"That's How You Know"
(Enchanted)
Sure, it sounded good, but the whirly,
squirrelly dancers were distracting, and
I secretly (viciously) wanted someone to
fall.
Best Song Presentation
"Falling Slowly"
(Once)
It could've sounded better, but that's
how I like to see Oscar-nominated songs
performed: no silly dance numbers or
props...just performers on an unadorned
stage.
Worst Shout-Out
Jon Stewart comparing Julie Christie's
portrayal of an Alzheimer's patient who
forgets her husband to Hilary Swank
forgetting to mention her husband during
her Oscar acceptance speech several
years ago. Considering Swank has split
from her husband, this was a low blow,
even for Stewart.
Best Shout-Out
Jon Stewart mentioning Angelina Jolie
couldn't attend the Oscars because it's
"hard to find 17 babysitters". One of
the few times Stewart made me laugh.
Least Deserving of an Oscar Nomination
Ruby Dee
(Supporting Actress, American
Gangster)
Yes, she's due. But, come on! A
performance that lasts 5 minutes is a
bit part, not a supporting role.
Most Deserving of an Oscar Nomination
Ellen Page
(Actress, Juno)
Her sweet and funny portrayal of a
pregnant teen was definitely
Oscar-worthy.
Least Deserving of an Oscar
Everyone that got one this year actually
deserved it.
Most Deserving of an Oscar
There really was no "most" deserving.
Least Surprising Winner
Daniel Day-Lewis
(Actor, There Will Be Blood)
I would've been shocked had anyone else
won.
Most Surprising Winner
No real surprises...no upsets.
Worst Presenters
Seth Rogan and
Jonah Hill
Their "I'm Halle Berry, you're Judi
Dench" schtick just went on and on and
on. And on. It wasn't even funny to
begin with.
Best Presenters
Military personnel beamed in by
satellite from Iraq
Yeah, it was a bit hokey, but I thought
it was very, very cool.
Worst Reaction of a Winner
Hugh Welchman
(Animated Short Film, Peter & the
Wolf)
Taking a leisurely stroll from the back
rows cradling a little Peter [snicker]
doll, Welchman looked like his win was a
foregone conclusion and he could just do
whatever he wanted.
Best Reaction of a Winner
Marion Cotillard
(Actress, La Vie en Rose)
So thrilled and excited, Cotillard was
barely able to contain herself as she
just repeated "thank you". Nice that she
avoided the blubbery blah-blah so common
to those in this category.
Biggest Loser
Gary Busey
During E!'s red carpet show, Busey, who
seemed to be "altered", first shouted at
Ryan Seacrest, then grabbed a surprised
Jennifer Garner (who didn't seem to know
who he was) in a bear hug and gave her a
big kiss. It frightened Garner and
totally unhinged Seacrest.
Shorter than many broadcasts at around 3
hours, 50 minutes, this Oscar telecast
was neither exciting, nor boring. It
just...was. The stage
looked very silly with its big tubey
things that reminded me so much of a
microscope and the opening montage was
decidedly uninspired (and I was
completely disgusted by the ads that
followed). What I found most annoying,
however, was that the images shown on
the giant screen had the edges cut off
when broadcast. I have a widescreen TV
(as so many do these days), so why were
so many titles chopped off? It made for
many interesting titles, however -
especially during the "Best Picture"
montage (where most of the years of the
movies was "19"). Some of my favorites:
ITANIC, LADIATOR, APE FEAR and (my
favorite), RASH. Didn't the producers
notice this during their
run-through?!?!?
The rest of the broadcast was just that:
a broadcast. Jon Stewart really sucked
as a host, I must say. I guess no one
told him he wasn't doing his show, but
the Oscars.
Not only did he seemed to be obsessed
with pregnant women and couldn't shut up
about them, he took every funny or sweet
moment and ruined it by poking fun.
There's a time to poke fun at things and
a time not to. At least Stewart was the
only one doing the political and social
spew (and it was brief), as everyone
else thankfully avoided the
all-too-common practice of using the
huge audience the broadcast garners as a
platform for the cause-of-the-minute.
For those who missed them:
Picture: No Country for Old Men,
Ethan Coen, Joel Coen, Scott Rudin
Director: Ethan Coen and Joel Coen,
No Country for Old Men
Actor: Daniel Day-Lewis, There
Will Be Blood
Actress: Marion Cotillard, La
Vie en Rose
Supporting Actor: Javier Bardem, No Country for Old Men
Supporting Actress: Tilda Swinton,
Michael Clayton
Foreign Language Film: Die
Fälscher (The Counterfeiters)
(Austria), Stefan Ruzowitzky
Cinematography: There Will Be
Blood,
Robert Elswit
Original Screenplay: Diablo Cody, Juno
Adapted Screenplay: Ethan Coen and Joel
Coen, No Country for Old Men
Documentary Feature: Taxi to
the Dark Side,
Alex Gibney, Eva Orner
Documentary Short Subject:
Freeheld,
Cynthia Wade, Vanessa Roth
Live Action Short Film: Le
Mozart des Pickpockets (The Mozart of
Pickpockets),
Philippe Pollet-Villard
Film Editing: The Bourne
Ultimatum,
Christopher Rouse
Makeup: La Vie en Rose,
Didier Lavergne, Jan Archibald
Art Direction: Sweeney Todd:
The Demon Barber of Fleet Street,
Dante Ferretti, Francesca lo Schiavo
Sound Mixing: The Bourne
Ultimatum,
Scott Millan, David Parker, Kirk Francis
Sound Editing: The Bourne
Ultimatum,
Karen Baker Landers, Per Hallberg
Visual Effects: The Golden
Compass,
Michel Fink, Bill Westenhofer, Ben
Morris, Trevor Wood
Costume Design: Elizabeth: The
Golden Age,
Alexandra Byrne
Original Score: Atonement,
Dario Marianelli
Original Song: "Falling Slowly", Once,
Glen Hansard, Marketa Irglova
Animated Feature Film:
Ratatouille,
Brad Bird
Animated Short Film: Peter &
the Wolf,
Suzie Templeton, Hugh Welchman
Honorary Oscar: Robert Boyle
We
would love to know what you think, sound off on the
TV message
boards and let us know what you think!